CAPTCHA vs Honeypot Method | Which is Better?
Honeypot method is often pointed as the most natural alternative to a captcha and praised for its zero user-friction nature, but can it truly replace captchas?
What is Honeypot Method?
Honeypot is a network security mechanism that acts as a decoy to detect, deflect and study the unauthorized use of IT systems.
When it comes to bot defense the honeypot method is often referred to hidden form fields, which are invisible to regular users. Bot programs, however, can still see and interact with these hidden form fields. Since a regular user can’t interact with the hidden field, upon any interaction, the site owner is alerted to the presence of an automated program. Once detected, the bots can be either blocked or fed with fake data.
There are more sophisticated ways to use honeypots - such as “dynamic honeypots” - and they can be utilized on different parts of network defense in effective ways. However, these are different from the anti-spam honey pots that are often presented as captcha alternatives.
Can Honeypot Method Replace CAPTCHA?
The honeypots in the form of hidden or invisible form fields can indeed stop spambots if the bot is named Winnie the Pooh. Apart from that, this kind of methods are nothing but a joke against the bot threats that the modern internet is dealing with today. Even a bot program that can be considered ‘not sophisticated’ can detect and avoid such traps.
It is simply insufficient to rely solely on honeypots to prevent spambots. Most CAPTCHA solutions -enterprise-grade or not- will give hackers a harder time and should be used instead. If you have a personal blog or a small website, an in-house captcha and a honeypot may suffice your needs. Still, if your website grows to attract any significant traffic, then it will likely become a target for attackers, in which case you should be prepared -starting with an advanced captcha- before any monetary or reputational damage occurs.